Can Operator Experience Help Classify Service Lines? A Q&A on the EPA's Latest Inventory Guidance
Lead & Copper Rule
LSL Inventory
LSL Verification

Every distribution system has someone who knows it better than the records do. The operator who has tapped more new connections than anyone can count. The crew lead who has seen service line after service line on main replacement jobs.
That knowledge has always been valuable. Under the Lead and Copper Rule Improvements (LCRI), it may also count as evidence. The EPA's August 2026 LCRI Service Line Inventories – Tips names water system personnel experience as an information source systems may use to classify service lines, as long as their primacy agency approves it.
Here are common questions about this approach, and what the guidance says.
Where does this fit in the inventory timeline?
Water systems submitted their initial service line inventories under the Lead and Copper Rule Revisions (LCRR) by October 16, 2024. Many are now refining that work ahead of the LCRI baseline inventory, due November 1, 2027.
The EPA requires systems to identify service line materials using records. These include construction and plumbing codes, water system records, and distribution system inspection records. Other evidence-based sources can be used to show a line is non-lead, but only with primacy agency approval.
Personnel experience falls into that second bucket.
What counts as personnel experience, and can any utility use it?
Personnel experience is documented knowledge from staff who have worked hands-on in the distribution system. That makes this approach most useful exactly where records say little or nothing about service line material.
It also comes with three key conditions:
- Primacy agency approval comes first. Personnel documentation can support classification only if the agency approves it.
- Each primacy agency may set its own expectations for how staff knowledge gets recorded.
- Validation still applies. Lines classified as non-lead this way stay in the LCRI validation pool.
Some primacy agencies already accept this type of evidence. Others are still evaluating it in light of the new Tips document.
What should the documentation include?
"I've never seen a lead line" is a memory. A primacy agency needs evidence. The EPA recommends that any statement include enough supporting information for the agency to judge how reliable it is.
A strong submission may include:
- Credentials: job title, certification level, and years of service.
- Responsibilities: duties tied to the distribution system, such as new connections and maintenance.
- Basis of knowledge: roughly how many service lines were examined, and across which areas and building ages.
- Findings: an explicit statement that no lead service lines were encountered.
- Colleague accounts: experience from other current and former staff, including how many lines they observed and whether any were lead.
- Independent corroboration: signed statements from sources outside the water system, such as plumbing code inspectors.
- Declaration: a signed statement that the information is true and correct to the best of the signer's knowledge and belief.
Think of it as a chain of custody form for institutional memory.
Can personnel experience support changing GRR to non-lead?
Sometimes, depending on your state and your system's history.
Galvanized service lines must be classified as galvanized requiring replacement (GRR) if they are or ever were downstream of a lead service line (LSL), or are currently downstream of a lead status unknown line. If a system cannot show that a galvanized line was never downstream of lead, it is a GRR.
The EPA guidance encourages systems to use other methods, with primacy agency approval, to show that LSLs never existed in all or part of the distribution system. Galvanized lines in those areas would then not be GRR.
Some states are starting to align with this. Virginia's GRR protocol, for example, allows personnel experience to support a GRR to non-lead classification under certain circumstances. Other primacy agencies are still weighing whether and how it fits their objectives.
One important limit: personnel experience is a weak basis for this call where LSLs are present today or have been documented in the community. Known lead contradicts a claim that lead was never used.
What does this mean for primacy agencies and utilities?
For primacy agencies, the decision is now on the table: whether to allow documented personnel experience, under what circumstances, and with what documentation.
Utilities can start here:
- Ask your primacy agency whether it accepts personnel experience and how it wants it documented.
- Talk to current and former staff. Their accounts can strengthen a submission, so reach out while they are still easy to find.
When records have gaps, low-cost options are limited, and documented experience is one of them. Galvanized lines that a system reclassifies from GRR to non-lead through a primacy agency-approved method still stay in the LCRI non-lead validation pool.
Get Your Inventory to Known
The November 1, 2027 baseline is coming, and every unknown line is work still ahead. 120Utility brings service line inventories, predictive modeling, and verification workflows into one connected system. For states, 120State gives program managers real-time visibility into inventory progress across every system they oversee.
Want to see how it fits your program? Talk to our team.

.png)
.png)